Orchestrated Idealism is an ontological framework that posits universal phenomenal consciousness as the fundamental ground of reality. It resolves the hard problem of consciousness by inverting the materialist paradigm. Instead of viewing consciousness as an emergent property of complex matter, it defines matter as the extrinsic, perceptible appearance of trans-personal mental processes. Within this framework, individual, subjective consciousness is a localized, self-organizing state of high coherence achieved through a specific biophysical mechanism.
The universe is a unitary field of phenomenal consciousness. What are termed the "laws of physics" are not prescriptive rules governing inert matter, but rather descriptive constants representing the stable, self-consistent dynamics of this universal mentation. Energy and mass are properties of this field, and spacetime is the structural form of its expression.
Organisms, particularly their nervous systems, are not generators of consciousness. They are the physical representation of a dissociated complex of mentation within the universal field. A brain is the empirical, observable correlate of a localized whirlpool of thought, feeling, and perception. The boundary of this complex, its informational separation from the rest of the universal field, is represented physically by the organism's Markov blanket.
For a dissociated mental complex to achieve unified, subjective self-awareness, its constituent mental processes must achieve a state of high informational integration. This state of integration is physically instantiated as macroscopic quantum coherence. The biological function of neuronal microtubules, under this model, is to act as quantum resonators that isolate and orchestrate this coherence, shielding the superposition from environmental decoherence long enough for a meaningful computation to occur. This biological facilitation is the "orchestration" component.
A discrete moment of phenomenal experience, or a "quale", is ontologically identical to the collapse of the orchestrated, coherent superposition. This is not a random, environment-induced decoherence but a non-computable, deterministic process known as Objective Reduction (OR). As defined by the Penrose-Diósi criterion, this self-collapse occurs when the superposition reaches a critical threshold of spacetime curvature (E=ħ/t), constituting a fundamental event. Each such event is a single, indivisible frame of conscious experience.
Orchestrated Idealism rejects the premise that consciousness is an epiphenomenon or emergent property of non-conscious components. The "explanatory gap" is a category error produced by a false ontological assumption. Under Orchestrated Idealism, the correlation between brain states and conscious states exists because the brain is the appearance of the conscious state, not its cause.
Panpsychism posits consciousness as a fundamental property of all matter, aggregating from simple micro-experiences in particles to complex macro-experiences in brains (a "bottom-up" approach). Orchestrated Idealism is a "top-down" model. There is one universal consciousness, and complex, individuated subjects are formed through the dissociation and subsequent coherent reintegration of segments of this field, not by combining smaller conscious units.
-
The framework posits that the non-computable, non-deterministic nature of Objective Reduction provides a physical basis for genuine mental causation and volition, distinct from both deterministic classical physics and random quantum events.
-
Furthermore, it predicts that experimental validation of the Orch-OR model, such as detecting quantum coherence in microtubules lasting for timescales relevant to cognition (25ms and beyond), would serve as direct empirical support for the physical mechanism required by the broader idealist ontology. The degree of measured coherence within a system would directly correlate to the degree of phenomenal unity and subjective richness experienced by the associated mental complex.