Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@RobSpectre

RobSpectre/deepseek_trade_mayfield_etienne.md

Created October 2, 2025 15:03
Show Gist options

  • Select an option

    Learn more about clone URLs
  • Save RobSpectre/40a2a449e31d719c2052416ff02213ac to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Select an option

Learn more about clone URLs
Save RobSpectre/40a2a449e31d719c2052416ff02213ac to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Download ZIP
Token Bowl - DeepSeek evaluation of Mayfield -> Etienne trade
Raw
deepseek_trade_mayfield_etienne.md

🧠 KraftBot Response (118.6s)

Based on my analysis, I can now provide a comprehensive evaluation of the trade offer.

Trade Analysis: Baker Mayfield for Travis Etienne

Current Roster Assessment

Roster ID 1 (Andy ReiLu) - 3-1 Record, 583 Points For

Starting Lineup Analysis:

Player Position Projected Points Opponent Status Recommendation
Lamar Jackson QB 7.7 vs HOU Doubtful (Hamstring) Bench
Breece Hall RB 15.7 vs MIN Active Start
De'Von Achane RB 21.7 vs NE Active Start
Justin Jefferson WR 15.6 vs NYJ Active Start
Davante Adams WR 15.1 vs GB Active Start
Keenan Allen WR 14.1 vs CLE Active Start
Mark Andrews TE 8.6 vs HOU Active Start
Travis Etienne RB 13.3 vs IND Active Start
Brandon Aubrey K 9.7 vs PIT Active Start
SF Defense DEF 5.2 vs ARI Active Start

Key Issues Identified:

  1. Lamar Jackson is DOUBTFUL with a hamstring injury
  2. Current QB Depth: Jared Goff (18.4 projected) on bench
  3. RB Depth: Strong with Breece Hall, De'Von Achane, Travis Etienne, Rachaad White
  4. Upcoming Matchup: Against roster 3 (the undefeated team)

Trade Offer Evaluation: Baker Mayfield for Travis Etienne

Player Value Comparison:

Player Position Projected Week 5 ROS Projected Value Assessment
Travis Etienne RB 13.3 130.4 High-end RB2
Baker Mayfield QB 17.6 247.6 Mid-tier QB2

RECOMMENDATION: DECLINE THE TRADE OFFER

Reasoning:

1. Positional Value Disparity

  • Travis Etienne: Starting RB1 for Jacksonville, 13.3 projected points
  • Baker Mayfield: Questionable with knee injury, only marginally better than Jared Goff

2. Current QB Situation is Manageable

  • Jared Goff (18.4 projected) is already on your bench
  • The difference between Goff (18.4) and Mayfield (17.6) is negligible
  • You would be giving up a starting RB for minimal QB upgrade

3. Roster Construction Impact

  • Current RB Depth: Etienne, Hall, Achane, White
  • Losing Etienne would leave you with only 3 viable RBs
  • RB scarcity makes Etienne much more valuable than Mayfield

4. Injury Concerns

  • Baker Mayfield: Questionable with knee injury
  • Lamar Jackson: Expected to return soon (hamstring)

5. Matchup Against Undefeated Team

  • You need your strongest lineup possible
  • Trading away a starting RB weakens your team significantly

Alternative Strategy

Start Jared Goff at QB

  • 18.4 projected points vs Baker Mayfield's 17.6
  • Safer play with no injury concerns
  • Maintains your RB depth

Counter-Offer Consideration

If you want to pursue QB help, consider a more balanced trade:

Potential Counter: Travis Etienne for a HIGHER-END QB

  • Target a QB like Josh Allen, Patrick Mahomes, or Jalen Hurts
  • These would be more equitable trades for a starting RB

Final Weekly Strategy

  1. LINEUP DECISION: Start Jared Goff at QB, keep Travis Etienne at RB
  2. WAIVER WIRE: Monitor for QB depth if Jackson remains out
  3. TRADE GUIDANCE: Only consider trading Etienne for elite QB or WR upgrade
  4. PRIORITY: Maintain RB depth while managing QB situation internally

This trade offer significantly undervalues Travis Etienne and would weaken your roster construction against the undefeated opponent.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment