Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@huttj

huttj/defender_data_2.json

Created November 2, 2025 03:24
Show Gist options

  • Select an option

    Learn more about clone URLs
  • Save huttj/b6b9c0151f0ce1a07f0d1d2769b44204 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Select an option

Learn more about clone URLs
Save huttj/b6b9c0151f0ce1a07f0d1d2769b44204 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Download ZIP
Raw
defender_data_2.json
{
"axes": [
{ "label": "Openness / Discourse Posture", "positive": "Open / bridge-building", "negative": "Hostile / combative" },
{ "label": "Ontology", "positive": "Constructivist / subjective / memetic", "negative": "Deterministic / realist" },
{ "label": "Agency Locus", "positive": "Collective / egregoric / networked", "negative": "Individual / atomized" },
{ "label": "Method Style", "positive": "Speculative / philosophical / mythic", "negative": "Empirical / pragmatic / testable" },
{ "label": "System Design Bias", "positive": "Decentralized / bottom-up / plural", "negative": "Centralized / top-down / singular" },
{ "label": "Tooling & Interventionism", "positive": "Engineer / build / intervene", "negative": "Observe / minimal intervention" }
],
"categories": [
{ "id": "OME", "label": "Open Memetics Engineers", "coords": [70, 55, 30, -10, 60, 85] },
{ "id": "EGO", "label": "Egregore Cartographers", "coords": [65, 60, 80, 15, 50, 60] },
{ "id": "SUBJ", "label": "Subjective Science Advocates", "coords": [60, 70, 20, 25, 40, 40] },
{ "id": "IEC", "label": "Info Ecology Reformers (anti–perfect-info fallacy, EMH nuance)", "coords": [55, 20, 35, -30, 40, 65] },
{ "id": "COORD", "label": "Coordination & Faith Pragmatists", "coords": [75, 45, 55, 10, 35, 55] },
{ "id": "ART", "label": "Aesthetic/Artisanal Memetics", "coords": [45, 50, 15, 35, 30, 35] },
{ "id": "SPIR", "label": "Spiritual / Metaphysical Aphorisms", "coords": [50, 65, 40, 60, 25, 25] },
{ "id": "TOOL", "label": "Practical Tooling & Experiments", "coords": [50, 25, 30, -45, 55, 90] },
{ "id": "ATTR", "label": "Credit / Linking / Field-building", "coords": [80, 35, 30, -25, 45, 55] },
{ "id": "ASK", "label": "Inquiry / Clarification Prompts", "coords": [70, 30, 20, 0, 30, 20] }
],
"data": {
"1963603550581182810": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ART","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Praises a memetics book (free online), blends rigor + beauty, and evangelizes it to the field.",
"coords": [65, 55, 25, 10, 35, 40]
},
"1984753885874176456": {
"categories": ["IEC","TOOL","OME"],
"explanation": "Proposes marketing that only states verifiable truths and teaches verification; market-shaping via customer discernment.",
"coords": [60, 10, 20, -35, 45, 85]
},
"1984796460748087438": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Requests an ELI5 elaboration; open, curious stance.",
"coords": [85, 20, 10, 0, 20, 10]
},
"1984761693067755967": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Brief affirmative engagement; low-content but friendly signal.",
"coords": [70, 0, 10, 0, 10, 5]
},
"1984696285262225616": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Attributes hope to Morphenius’s writing; nod to subjective science lineage.",
"coords": [70, 60, 20, 20, 25, 35]
},
"1984686167405560132": {
"categories": ["TOOL","OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Describes plotting replies along hostile↔open using Postscope; reflexive measurement of discourse posture.",
"coords": [55, 25, 30, -35, 55, 90]
},
"1984686170039529551": {
"categories": ["TOOL","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Credits Postscope paradigm and origin; emphasizes local scraping/bookmarklet approach.",
"coords": [60, 25, 25, -45, 60, 85]
},
"1984632773953413386": {
"categories": ["IEC","COORD","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Introduces fard kifayah to nuance EMH: efficiency via communal sufficiency, not universality.",
"coords": [55, 20, 45, 5, 35, 45]
},
"1984633198765044045": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","TOOL","ATTR"],
"explanation": "OMI design: check claims relative to your network; cites subjective science essays.",
"coords": [65, 65, 35, -10, 45, 60]
},
"1984614610029129860": {
"categories": ["IEC","OME"],
"explanation": "Notes imperfect info networks; identifies opportunity for bug-fixing and memetic engineering.",
"coords": [55, 15, 25, -25, 35, 70]
},
"1984614903953395929": {
"categories": ["IEC","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Coins the 'perfect information environment' fallacy; analogy to EMH for info networks.",
"coords": [60, 15, 20, -20, 30, 55]
},
"1984645720767352962": {
"categories": ["ART","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Appreciates an essay where a simple question reveals a full system.",
"coords": [55, 55, 15, 25, 25, 30]
},
"1984645731114791088": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Links source essay; credit/field-building function.",
"coords": [75, 30, 15, -10, 25, 30]
},
"1984637367886758379": {
"categories": ["ASK","COORD"],
"explanation": "Queries about churches investing in tech; probing hidden coordination structures.",
"coords": [65, 35, 40, 10, 20, 25]
},
"1984645319225983117": {
"categories": ["EGO","TOOL","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Proposes ‘dark memetics hotline’ for secret societies to request without revealing themselves.",
"coords": [45, 55, 80, 25, 35, 70]
},
"1984371701291917623": {
"categories": ["SPIR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Aphorism: 'all knowable knowledge is related'—strong integrative ontology.",
"coords": [55, 65, 35, 50, 20, 20]
},
"1984633958051524751": {
"categories": ["ASK","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Seeks clarification on symbolic vs non-symbolic knowledge reconciliation.",
"coords": [75, 55, 20, 10, 20, 15]
},
"1984634098913001841": {
"categories": ["SUBJ"],
"explanation": "States axiom: any two truths must reconcile.",
"coords": [60, 70, 20, 20, 20, 20]
},
"1984614409038119079": {
"categories": ["ATTR","IEC"],
"explanation": "Frames role as science communication for scientists; recognizes others doing similar.",
"coords": [70, 25, 25, -15, 25, 45]
},
"1984614191190147214": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ASK"],
"explanation": "Shares GitHub notes/public correspondence; ongoing inquiry.",
"coords": [75, 30, 20, -10, 25, 35]
},
"1984598880051442154": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Shares link to Ogi Ogas superlearning.",
"coords": [65, 20, 15, -15, 20, 25]
},
"1984598989904257410": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ASK"],
"explanation": "Advises reading 'full disclosure' interview to contextualize the author’s mind.",
"coords": [70, 25, 15, -10, 20, 20]
},
"1984417797762367660": {
"categories": ["ART"],
"explanation": "Short artistic nudge: 'once more with feeling'.",
"coords": [50, 60, 10, 35, 15, 15]
},
"1984395992343470274": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","EGO"],
"explanation": "Notes frameworks are incomplete but completable via generalization.",
"coords": [55, 60, 35, 20, 20, 30]
},
"1984258767165509658": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Clarifies LLC vs A-corp equity sharing; practical inquiry.",
"coords": [65, 10, 10, -10, 15, 20]
},
"1984258840733647060": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Follows up on goal framing (share equity).",
"coords": [65, 10, 10, -10, 15, 15]
},
"1984209186604138830": {
"categories": ["ASK","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Asks if others have seen a thing; light discovery probe.",
"coords": [70, 25, 20, 0, 20, 20]
},
"1984276807567179791": {
"categories": ["IEC","EGO"],
"explanation": "Suggests platforms spread psychological toxins; 'live players' and social engineering as frontier.",
"coords": [20, 35, 60, 15, 30, 55]
},
"1984262890984194406": {
"categories": ["ART","IEC"],
"explanation": "Art project resonance; infohazard/‘planted thoughts’ frame.",
"coords": [35, 50, 30, 25, 20, 35]
},
"1984262999910252955": {
"categories": ["ATTR","IEC"],
"explanation": "Monitoring 'forgotten languages' project; notes and vigilance.",
"coords": [45, 35, 30, -5, 20, 35]
},
"1984057287850520648": {
"categories": ["SPIR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Aphorism on loving reality or a mind that loves reality; egregore/society health.",
"coords": [55, 70, 45, 55, 20, 20]
},
"1984262527954653332": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Meta about posting/poll fatigue; opt-in ethos.",
"coords": [70, 20, 15, -10, 20, 15]
},
"1984251975634980889": {
"categories": ["COORD","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Coordination via faith/assumption of better world; step toward highest leverage point.",
"coords": [75, 55, 55, 35, 30, 45]
},
"1984252118128308264": {
"categories": ["ART","COORD"],
"explanation": "Refers to depiction/diagram of the idea.",
"coords": [55, 50, 40, 25, 25, 35]
},
"1984221941134209130": {
"categories": ["IEC","COORD"],
"explanation": "World-end narratives as cybernetic feedback vs collapse modes; detection & response.",
"coords": [45, 25, 50, 0, 35, 50]
},
"1984217493842612232": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Sources images from Pinterest/Reddit.",
"coords": [65, 15, 10, -10, 15, 15]
},
"1984058761527562570": {
"categories": ["OME","COORD"],
"explanation": "Etiquette for open memetics engineer—disclose when 'working' on minds/egregores.",
"coords": [70, 45, 45, -10, 40, 55]
},
"1984214399201206625": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ASK"],
"explanation": "Acknowledges idea lineage and intent to try it.",
"coords": [75, 20, 15, -10, 20, 20]
},
"1984211865061539995": {
"categories": ["IEC","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Medium targeting/assumption critique: messages aren’t always ‘for me’.",
"coords": [45, 35, 20, 5, 20, 25]
},
"1984209189309386753": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Credits reporter of a find.",
"coords": [80, 20, 15, -15, 20, 20]
},
"1984203687791866058": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Requests expansion on 'U' reaction.",
"coords": [70, 15, 10, 0, 15, 15]
},
"1984201957561823652": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Open prompt: 'say more?'",
"coords": [80, 15, 10, 0, 15, 10]
},
"1984202855792980452": {
"categories": ["OME","COORD"],
"explanation": "Discloses memetic inference in social settings; boundary ethics.",
"coords": [70, 35, 35, -5, 35, 45]
},
"1984203394761081151": {
"categories": ["OME"],
"explanation": "Reiterates disclosure norm; cannot promise not to infer.",
"coords": [65, 25, 30, -10, 35, 40]
},
"1984203292516438420": {
"categories": ["ATTR","OME"],
"explanation": "Frames as 'writer' practice to normalize inspiration-gathering.",
"coords": [70, 20, 25, -10, 30, 35]
},
"1984203141014053245": {
"categories": ["OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Conflict of interest framing for involuntary insights in social learning.",
"coords": [60, 20, 30, -15, 30, 40]
},
"1984202346029867168": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Levin analogy: cells with/without governance interacting with reality.",
"coords": [55, 55, 40, 25, 20, 25]
},
"1984202455006257621": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Points to specific segment of talk.",
"coords": [65, 15, 15, -10, 15, 15]
},
"1984064308666573115": {
"categories": ["IEC","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Aphorism: 'don’t feed the parasites'—memetic hygiene.",
"coords": [35, 40, 35, 20, 15, 35]
},
"1984064249656963333": {
"categories": ["ASK","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Questions whether 'symmetry' is neutral to reality.",
"coords": [65, 55, 20, 15, 15, 15]
},
"1984056917648630101": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Direct challenge: 'why is it bullshit'.",
"coords": [55, 10, 10, 0, 10, 10]
},
"1984054785042215047": {
"categories": ["ATTR","OME"],
"explanation": "OMI prides itself on giving credit; culture-setting.",
"coords": [85, 30, 30, -15, 40, 45]
},
"1983864705740353632": {
"categories": ["EGO","IEC"],
"explanation": "Defines egregore velocity as speed of desired info propagation.",
"coords": [50, 40, 75, -5, 35, 55]
},
"1984033044790227162": {
"categories": ["TOOL","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Emphasizes templates/containers over specific discussions.",
"coords": [55, 20, 25, -25, 50, 70]
},
"1984026248641913207": {
"categories": ["EGO","TOOL","COORD"],
"explanation": "Seeks a consenting model egregore (open memetics cluster) for mapping.",
"coords": [60, 50, 85, -10, 55, 75]
},
"1984026422747476048": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Excited about GitHub debate/dissection of terms; staging next experiment.",
"coords": [70, 25, 25, -30, 50, 70]
},
"1983704562465902869": {
"categories": ["ART","IEC"],
"explanation": "Contrasts mass art vs many-to-many creation; distribution topology.",
"coords": [45, 45, 25, 20, 40, 30]
},
"1984019197249434071": {
"categories": ["ART"],
"explanation": "Claims elite outputs require refined taste.",
"coords": [30, 40, 15, 30, 15, 15]
},
"1984016074850144569": {
"categories": ["ASK","ART"],
"explanation": "Short suggestion/question: 'local theater?'",
"coords": [60, 25, 10, 5, 10, 10]
},
"1984016214944051623": {
"categories": ["ASK","ART","IEC"],
"explanation": "Is popularity correlated with quality?",
"coords": [55, 20, 10, 5, 15, 10]
},
"1983988449184301485": {
"categories": ["IEC","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Uses CPU/cache analogy for multiple overlapping frequencies in comms.",
"coords": [45, 20, 30, -10, 25, 45]
},
"1983899323344810140": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL","OME"],
"explanation": "PR to glossary adding 'epistemic noise' & 'desired/pulled meme'; requests reviews.",
"coords": [70, 25, 30, -40, 50, 85]
},
"1983641503202197670": {
"categories": ["TOOL","IEC"],
"explanation": "Observes common answer 'find joy' in million-view tweet analysis.",
"coords": [55, 20, 25, -20, 40, 60]
},
"1983908462653235632": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Links Postscope readme; practical pointer.",
"coords": [65, 20, 20, -35, 50, 75]
},
"1983985903015227863": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Argues best language is local; mediating across mind categories at chosen level.",
"coords": [60, 65, 25, 15, 35, 35]
},
"1983947384326426720": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Glossary as shared technical language; not aiming for mass adoption.",
"coords": [55, 25, 25, -20, 45, 55]
},
"1983947703206674510": {
"categories": ["TOOL","IEC"],
"explanation": "Defines 'epistemic noise' intuitively; includes true info as subcase.",
"coords": [50, 15, 20, -25, 35, 55]
},
"1983901631721713708": {
"categories": ["ART","COORD"],
"explanation": "Compares game jams vs centralized blog contests; decentralized creative coordination.",
"coords": [60, 40, 35, 10, 55, 40]
},
"1983899326221861367": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "PR pointer; housekeeping.",
"coords": [70, 15, 15, -20, 35, 45]
},
"1983714188448165972": {
"categories": ["IEC","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Critiques assumption of 'zero cultural pressure' as neutral baseline.",
"coords": [40, 45, 20, 10, 20, 25]
},
"1983882324677681332": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Reality as arbiter: choice influences real, but instability disqualifies.",
"coords": [55, 60, 30, 35, 20, 25]
},
"1983882544333676562": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","IEC"],
"explanation": "Multiple voices shape reality; final authority is what reality allows.",
"coords": [50, 55, 35, 25, 20, 25]
},
"1983875540453900357": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ART"],
"explanation": "Thanks for sharing something beautiful.",
"coords": [75, 35, 15, 20, 15, 15]
},
"1983875717814178240": {
"categories": ["ART","SPIR"],
"explanation": "Triangles aphorism: essence vs demagoguery of change.",
"coords": [45, 55, 20, 40, 15, 15]
},
"1983857613713396197": {
"categories": ["IEC","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Maintain feedback loops; design for detectable failure.",
"coords": [55, 10, 30, -35, 45, 70]
},
"1983857685847273937": {
"categories": ["IEC","TOOL","OME"],
"explanation": "Surface vs solve: community notes > fact checking; agency-increasing systems.",
"coords": [65, 20, 35, -25, 55, 65]
},
"1908957396371997182": {
"categories": ["TOOL","OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Idea spikes timeline; Overton window alerts; public access to lab-grade tools.",
"coords": [60, 25, 40, -40, 60, 90]
},
"1983849544711598305": {
"categories": ["ATTR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Invites specific peers to validate/create axioms.",
"coords": [70, 60, 20, 10, 30, 35]
},
"1974018163961442543": {
"categories": ["IEC","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Frontier/backtier gap explains 'sounding crazy'; social epistemology.",
"coords": [50, 25, 20, 5, 25, 25]
},
"1983847864368558277": {
"categories": ["IEC"],
"explanation": "Most people hold science on trust; inability to personally verify.",
"coords": [35, 10, 10, -5, 10, 10]
},
"1983847335450046568": {
"categories": ["ASK"],
"explanation": "Clarifies question being answered.",
"coords": [70, 10, 10, 0, 10, 10]
},
"1983852283264954598": {
"categories": ["ASK","ART"],
"explanation": "Asks how artifacts are made.",
"coords": [65, 15, 10, 0, 10, 15]
},
"1983712604930633882": {
"categories": ["OME","IEC","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Defines open memetics via 'ideal information environment' and measuring deltas.",
"coords": [70, 25, 35, -35, 55, 85]
},
"1983849420929036611": {
"categories": ["OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Claims tangible value from the 'ideal info environment' question (e.g., peer review).",
"coords": [65, 20, 30, -25, 45, 70]
},
"1983657035083440335": {
"categories": ["ART"],
"explanation": "Self-reflection on collage impulse behind tech work.",
"coords": [50, 55, 15, 30, 20, 20]
},
"1983846032858325215": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Meta on novelty vs truth claim attribution.",
"coords": [65, 20, 15, 0, 15, 15]
},
"1983715103523664080": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Following a line of inquiry closely.",
"coords": [60, 20, 20, -10, 25, 40]
},
"1983714190767345847": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","IEC"],
"explanation": "People push back because 'true self' involves chosen normality standards.",
"coords": [45, 55, 20, 20, 20, 25]
},
"1983680638701224199": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "Points to an item with emphasis ('this:').",
"coords": [60, 15, 10, -5, 10, 10]
},
"1983641505404445053": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Notes cool clustering of inspect-based analogies side-by-side.",
"coords": [60, 20, 20, -20, 45, 55]
},
"1983642078434177062": {
"categories": ["TOOL","IEC"],
"explanation": "Wants to compute outlier-of-outliers in reply clusters; Levin on an island.",
"coords": [55, 20, 25, -25, 50, 70]
},
"1983534264072503314": {
"categories": ["ATTR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Signals Levin’s theme: against mind blindness.",
"coords": [60, 55, 35, 15, 20, 25]
},
"1983534601600389496": {
"categories": ["ATTR"],
"explanation": "References talk timestamps.",
"coords": [65, 15, 15, -10, 15, 15]
},
"1983530322223374554": {
"categories": ["EGO","IEC"],
"explanation": "Defines egregore as a mind; probe awareness via responses.",
"coords": [55, 45, 80, -5, 35, 55]
},
"1983530605808882122": {
"categories": ["EGO","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Boundary of egregores is fuzzy but definable; cites Blaise Aguera.",
"coords": [60, 55, 70, 5, 30, 40]
},
"1979666265200570762": {
"categories": ["ASK","IEC"],
"explanation": "Asks whether simple minds can do what complex minds cannot; seeks examples.",
"coords": [65, 25, 10, 5, 15, 15]
},
"1983539622321021186": {
"categories": ["SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Affirms being a simple mind isn’t bad.",
"coords": [60, 50, 15, 15, 15, 15]
},
"1983354338329407566": {
"categories": ["OME","ATTR"],
"explanation": "States onboarding test: model of ideal info environment is table stakes.",
"coords": [70, 25, 30, -30, 50, 75]
},
"1983528867903246705": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ASK"],
"explanation": "Open to renaming; placeholder naming discussion.",
"coords": [70, 15, 15, 0, 20, 20]
},
"1983529522634121592": {
"categories": ["ATTR","TOOL"],
"explanation": "Opened an issue linking this debate; process hygiene.",
"coords": [70, 20, 20, -25, 45, 55]
},
"1983526893300138372": {
"categories": ["SUBJ","ATTR"],
"explanation": "Notes axioms become invisible with use; only visible in conversation.",
"coords": [60, 60, 20, 20, 25, 25]
},
"1983527144736395508": {
"categories": ["OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Axiom: Virality is predictable, not random.",
"coords": [55, 20, 25, -20, 35, 65]
},
"1983525752919535629": {
"categories": ["ATTR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Links 'subjective science' as reference axiom source.",
"coords": [65, 60, 20, 15, 25, 25]
},
"1983525952673173861": {
"categories": ["ATTR","OME"],
"explanation": "State axioms briefly; separate advocacy from core work.",
"coords": [65, 25, 25, -15, 35, 45]
},
"1983522928286486531": {
"categories": ["ATTR","SUBJ"],
"explanation": "Again invites select peers to co-create axioms.",
"coords": [70, 55, 20, 10, 25, 30]
},
"1983522312562643393": {
"categories": ["OME","IEC"],
"explanation": "Air-traffic control metaphor for memetic operations.",
"coords": [55, 25, 35, -10, 40, 55]
},
"1983522367960760654": {
"categories": ["ATTR","ART"],
"explanation": "Resurfaces a favored reference.",
"coords": [65, 25, 15, 5, 20, 20]
},
"1983502941576155250": {
"categories": ["OME","EGO","IEC"],
"explanation": "Markov-like model of egregores predicts virality and reshapes landscape.",
"coords": [60, 25, 65, -20, 50, 75]
},
"1983515180291018964": {
"categories": ["TOOL","OME"],
"explanation": "Proposes blinded 10-tweet virality prediction test.",
"coords": [55, 15, 20, -40, 40, 80]
},
"1983512975672566179": {
"categories": ["IEC","OME"],
"explanation": "At small scale, authenticity detection enables prediction.",
"coords": [55, 20, 20, -15, 25, 50]
}
}
}
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment