Here is the complete classification.
Let
(the triangular set of lattice points that must be covered).
Call a line non‑sunny if it is parallel to one of the three sides of the triangle, i.e. it is of the form
Claim 1. In any admissible family of
must be chosen.
Proof. The
Remove
and the number of sunny lines does not change (since
Applying Claim 1 to this smaller triangle shows
Corollary. Every admissible family for
Consequently, after fixing those
Only three lines remain to cover
So the problem reduces to: Which numbers of sunny lines are possible when three lines must cover
The points of
-
$k=0$ is possible: take the three anti‑diagonals$$ D_2:\ x+y=2,\quad D_3:\ x+y=3,\quad D_4:\ x+y=4. $$
-
$k=1$ is possible: take$D_3, D_4$ and the sunny line$x=y$ (which covers$(1,1)$ and $(2,2)$). -
$k=3$ is possible: take the three sunny lines$$ \ell_1:\ x=y\quad(\text{through }(1,1),(2,2)),\qquad \ell_2:\ \text{through }(1,3)\text{ and }(2,1)\ (,\text{slope }-2,), $$
$$ \ell_3:\ \text{through }(1,2)\text{ and }(3,1)\ (,\text{slope }-{\tfrac12},). $$
These three cover all six points of
$T_3$ . -
$k=2$ is impossible: suppose two sunny lines and one non‑sunny line cover$T_3$ . Consider the three possibilities for the non‑sunny line:If it is $D_4$: the remaining points are
$(1,1),(1,2),(2,1)$ . Any line through two of these is vertical, horizontal, or slope$-1$ ; hence no sunny line contains two of them, so two sunny lines cannot cover all three points.If it is $x=1$: the remaining points are
$(2,1),(2,2),(3,1)$ . Again, any line through two of them is non‑sunny (vertical$x=2$ , horizontal$y=1$ , or slope$-1$ ), so two sunny lines cannot cover all three.If it is $y=1$: symmetric to the previous case.
Thus
$k=2$ cannot occur for$T_3$ .
Therefore, for
As shown above, for general
Finally, explicit constructions for all
-
$k=0$ : take all$n$ non‑sunny anti‑diagonals$x+y=2,3,\dots,n+1$ . -
$k=1$ : take$x+y=3,4,\dots,n+1$ together with the sunny line$x=y$ . -
$k=3$ : take$x+y=5,6,\dots,n+1$ together with the three sunny lines$\ell_1,\ell_2,\ell_3$ listed above.
Each set has exactly
Answer: For every integer